Mill Basin Bagel Cafe Menu

Mill Basin Bagel Cafe in Brooklyn offers a vibrant menu centered on fresh, authentic bagels and deli classics. Their diverse bagel varieties—from plain and sesame to specialty flavors like pumpernickel and cinnamon raisin—are the base for standout options like the savory bacon egg cheese and the creamy avocado on a roll. The schmears are a highlight, particularly the olive, vegetable, and the luscious scallion with bacon bits, each adding rich layers of flavor without the typical refrigerated taste often found elsewhere. The Fish Supreme, boasting a selection of Nova, Belly, or Sable salmon paired with cream cheese and capers, elevates traditional bagels to an elegant deli experience. Beyond bagels, the deli meats feature premium Boar's Head selections such as honey-glazed turkey and center cut roast beef, enhancing sandwiches like the classic BLT. Refreshing iced coffees and sweet treats like the strawberry croissant round out a menu that feels both comforting and refined, making every visit a satisfying adventure in Brooklyn’s bagel scene.